11-054-11-055 Report ocr 1 |
Previous | 1 of 8 | Next |
|
small (250x250 max)
medium (500x500 max)
Large
Extra Large
large ( > 500x500)
Full Resolution
All (PDF)
|
This page
All
|
INTERIM STUDY REPORT
Redistricting Committee
Rep. Dale DeWitt, Chairman
Oklahoma House of Representatives
Interim Study 11-054 & 11-055, Rep. Dale DeWitt
October 13, 2011
Judicial Redistricting – Statewide Courts
Judicial Redistricting – District Courts
Chief Justice Steven W. Taylor
Oklahoma Supreme Court
Chief Justice Taylor gave extensive comments on the general topic of judicial redistricting. His
key points included:
• The principle of “one person, one vote” does not apply to judicial redistricting because
judges do not have constituencies in the same manner as the Legislature.
o Judges decide cases based on the rule of law, not a political or geographic
constituency.
o Statewide judges do not campaign for office: they do not raise money, give
speeches, or campaign for the position.
o Also, population is not paramount in this issue: caseload and geography are
significant factors for consideration.
• The judiciary actually “redistricts” itself every day through the management of the courts.
o Judges can be moved around the state – and outside the district they are elected
from – in an effort to ease the caseload of other judges.
o This happens every day in Oklahoma.
• If the Oklahoma Legislature moves forward with judicial redistricting, the courts would
like to provide information and be included in the process.
Thad Balkman
Oklahoma Lawyers Association
tbalkman@oklawyers.org
Mr. Balkman presented what Oklahoma statute says about judicial redistricting. He noted that
while there is little procedural guidance in statute, there are some relevant sections.
See Presentation A
John Morris Williams
Executive Director, Oklahoma Bar Association
JohnW@okbar.org
Mr. Williams stated that the judicial system seems to be working well. The concept of judges
serving the entire state makes a difference, allowing the courts to deal with their caseloads. He
added that the Oklahoma Bar Association would like to assist the House should it move forward
with judicial redistricting.
Object Description
Description
| Title | 11-054-11-055 Report ocr 1 |
| Full text | INTERIM STUDY REPORT Redistricting Committee Rep. Dale DeWitt, Chairman Oklahoma House of Representatives Interim Study 11-054 & 11-055, Rep. Dale DeWitt October 13, 2011 Judicial Redistricting – Statewide Courts Judicial Redistricting – District Courts Chief Justice Steven W. Taylor Oklahoma Supreme Court Chief Justice Taylor gave extensive comments on the general topic of judicial redistricting. His key points included: • The principle of “one person, one vote” does not apply to judicial redistricting because judges do not have constituencies in the same manner as the Legislature. o Judges decide cases based on the rule of law, not a political or geographic constituency. o Statewide judges do not campaign for office: they do not raise money, give speeches, or campaign for the position. o Also, population is not paramount in this issue: caseload and geography are significant factors for consideration. • The judiciary actually “redistricts” itself every day through the management of the courts. o Judges can be moved around the state – and outside the district they are elected from – in an effort to ease the caseload of other judges. o This happens every day in Oklahoma. • If the Oklahoma Legislature moves forward with judicial redistricting, the courts would like to provide information and be included in the process. Thad Balkman Oklahoma Lawyers Association tbalkman@oklawyers.org Mr. Balkman presented what Oklahoma statute says about judicial redistricting. He noted that while there is little procedural guidance in statute, there are some relevant sections. See Presentation A John Morris Williams Executive Director, Oklahoma Bar Association JohnW@okbar.org Mr. Williams stated that the judicial system seems to be working well. The concept of judges serving the entire state makes a difference, allowing the courts to deal with their caseloads. He added that the Oklahoma Bar Association would like to assist the House should it move forward with judicial redistricting. |
| Date created | 2012-03-14 |
| Date modified | 2012-03-14 |
