Justice reinvestment in Oklahoma : town hall meetings

              Council of State Governments Justice Center | 1
Justice Reinvestment
in Oklahoma
Town Hall Meetings
October 17-18, 2011
Council of State Governments Justice Center
Marshall Clement, Project Director
Anne Bettesworth, Policy Analyst
Jessy Tyler, Senior Research Associate
Robert Coombs, Senior Policy Analyst
CSG Justice Center
Council of State Governments Justice Center | 2
• National non-profit, non-partisan
membership association of state government officials
• Represents all three branches of state government
• Justice Center provides practical, nonpartisan
advice informed by the best available evidence
Criminal Justice /
Mental Health
Consensus Project
Reentry Policy
Council
Justice
Reinvestment
Funders and Partners
Council of State Governments Justice Center | 3
November-January
Oklahoma Justice Reinvestment Process
4
Collect & examine
quantitative data
! Reported crime &
arrests
! Court dispositions &
sentencing
! DA supervision
! Probation and parole
supervision
! Prison admissions,
population & releases
Develop & present a
comprehensive analysis
of the state’s criminal
justice system
Develop a framework of
policy options that
together would increase
public safety and reduce/
avert taxpayer spending
June-October
July-October
Engage stakeholders
! Law enforcement
! Judges
! Prosecutors
! Defense bar
! Victim advocates/
survivors
! County officials
! Supervision agencies
! Behavioral health &
treatment providers
Analyze Data & Develop Policy Options
Past Justice Reinvestment States
Council of State Governments Justice Center | 5
Preliminary Analysis
Council of State Governments Justice Center | 6
!"#
$%&'()*#+,%-(##
!"#$%&''()*&+,-#.!/.0#
*.(#%$1+(2#34#)3,!'(#
)(2#'&)!*&#!%#*.2((#34#
*.(#,&2/("*#'!5("#.&"#
6(',!%(67#
#
."#
/01(,2%3%&)#4&,#
4('&)5#&6()7(,3#%3#
7(+'%)%)89#4(8(2#
)(3),(#&2(#+(!%/#
"$)(29!"(6#&:(2#
2(,(&"(#4231#)2!"3%7#
:"#
;<(#1,%3&)#
1&10'=>&)#%3#
8,&?%)8@#&%6#132(#
")(%6!%/#8!,,#+(#
2(;$!2(6#*3#!%'2(&"(#
'&)&'!*-#$%,(""#*.(#
)3)$,&53%#/238*.#!"#
1&%&/(67#
Violent Index Crimes Reported to Police
in Oklahoma Remained High
Council of State Governments Justice Center | 7 United States Department of Justice, Federal Bureau of Investigation. (September 2011).
Crime in the United States, 2000-2010. From
http://www.fbi.gov/about-us/cjis/ucr/crime-in-the-u.s/2010/crime-in-the-u.s.-2010.
<#
=><<<#
?><<<#
@><<<#
A><<<#
B<><<<#
B=><<<#
B?><<<#
B@><<<#
BA><<<#
=<><<<#
=<<<# =<<B# =<<=# =<<C# =<<?# =<<D# =<<@# =<<E# =<<A# =<<F# =<B<#
A&BB(,5#,=*(9##
GHI#JBDK#LMI#NBAK#
C0,7(,#,=*(9##
GHI#N=K#LMI#NBCK#
D88,=2=*(7#D33=0'*#
A&BB(,5#
E&,+%B'(#A=1(#
C0,7(,#
Violent Crime Rate & Law Enforcement Staffing Per Capita
2000-2010
Council of State Governments Justice Center | 8
!FG#
!!G#
HI'=<&-=#J%*5# ;0'3=# K=?*&)# L&,-=)#
O(2'(%*#
P.&%/(#!%#
$%&'()*#
J,%-(#A=*(#
Q##
K=?#
M)4&,+(-()*#
/*=N)8#O(,#
J=1%*=#
.G#
PG#
.PG#
!QG#
R:G#
J# !PG#
N#
Preliminary Analysis
Council of State Governments Justice Center | 9
!"#
$%&'()*#+,%-(##
!"#$%&''()*&+,-#.!/.0#
*.(#%$1+(2#34#)3,!'(#
)(2#'&)!*&#!%#*.2((#34#
*.(#,&2/("*#'!5("#.&"#
6(',!%(67#
#
."#
/01(,2%3%&)#4&,#
4('&)5#&6()7(,3#%3#
7(+'%)%)89#4(8(2#
)(3),(#&2(#+(!%/#
"$)(29!"(6#&:(2#
2(,(&"(#4231#)2!"3%7#
:"#
;<(#1,%3&)#
1&10'=>&)#%3#
8,&?%)8@#&%6#132(#
")(%6!%/#8!,,#+(#
2(;$!2(6#*3#!%'2(&"(#
'&)&'!*-#$%,(""#*.(#
)3)$,&53%#/238*.#!"#
1&%&/(67#
More and More People are Being
Released Unsupervised
Council of State Governments Justice Center | 10 Source: Oklahoma Department of Corrections, Evaluation and Analysis. (2011). The State
of Corrections in Oklahoma: Fiscal Year, 2010 http://www.doc.state.ok.us/
newsroom/annuals/2010/annualreport2010.pdf.
#C>CF@##
#C><@<##
#B>@DD##
#?>CD=##
#C>??<##
#E@B##
#N####
#D<<##
#B><<<##
#B>D<<##
#=><<<##
#=>D<<##
#C><<<##
#C>D<<##
#?><<<##
#?>D<<##
#D><<<##
L&#/01(,2%3%&)# O,&B=>&)# O=,&'(#
=<<D# =<B<#
The number of
offenders released
to parole
dropped in half
51%
released
unsupervised in
2010
Rearrests Within 36 Months of Release
Council of State Governments Justice Center | 11 OKDOC and OSBI raw data files of 2007 Prison Releases
E>@FC#
#L%!;$(#R(,(&"("#4231#SGP#T&'!,!5("#6$2!%/#TU=<<E#
:@SQS##
GV(%6(2"#W3*#R(&22("*(6#!%#C@#X3%*."#
R@QPF#
GV(%6(2"#R(&22("*(6#
!@TTT#
#
U(&2#B#
!@.TP#
#
U(&2#=#
FTQ#
#
U(&2#C#
DCK#
Y22("*(6#8!*.!%#C#-(&2"#34#
2(,(&"(#
?EK#
W3*#&22("*(6#8!*.!%#C#-(&2"#34#
2(,(&"(#
Preliminary Analysis
Council of State Governments Justice Center | 12
!"#
$%&'()*#+,%-(##
!"#$%&''()*&+,-#.!/.0#
*.(#%$1+(2#34#)3,!'(#
)(2#'&)!*&#!%#*.2((#34#
*.(#,&2/("*#'!5("#.&"#
6(',!%(67#
#
."#
/01(,2%3%&)#4&,#
4('&)5#&6()7(,3#%3#
7(+'%)%)89#4(8(2#
)(3),(#&2(#+(!%/#
"$)(29!"(6#&:(2#
2(,(&"(#4231#)2!"3%7#
:"#
;<(#1,%3&)#
1&10'=>&)#%3#
8,&?%)8@#&%6#132(#
")(%6!%/#8!,,#+(#
2(;$!2(6#*3#!%'2(&"(#
'&)&'!*-#$%,(""#*.(#
)3)$,&53%#/238*.#!"#
1&%&/(67#
#=@>@F=##
<#
D><<<#
B<><<<#
BD><<<#
=<><<<#
=D><<<#
C<><<<#
O2!"3%#O3)$,&53%# O2!"3%#Q#Z&!,#[&'\,3/#
Oklahoma’s Prison Population is Growing
Council of State Governments Justice Center | 13 OK: OKDOC Annual Reports 2009 and 2010
National: Sourcebook of criminal justice statistics
BFF@#N#=<B<I#JC?K#
=<<<#N#=<B<I#JBDK##
B>C=C#3V(%6(2"#8(2(#
+&'\,3//(6#!%#]&!,# ^#
Estimate of Growth in Prison Population
(Driven by accumulation of 85% offenders)
Council of State Governments Justice Center | 14 Oklahoma Department of Corrections, Entry and Exits, FY2005 to FY2011.
<#
D><<<#
B<><<<#
BD><<<#
=<><<<#
=D><<<#
C<><<<#
TU<D# TU<@# TU<E# TU<A# TU<F# TUB<# TUBB# TUB=# TUBC# TUB?# TUBD# TUB@# TUBE# TUBA# TUBF# TU=<# TU=B#
Z&!,#[&'\NL)# W3%NADK#O3)$,&53%# ADK#O3)$,&53%#
U:@!!Q# O23)&/&53%#X36(,##
#
PVG#O&10'=>&)##
Y""$1("#BK#!%'2(&"(#!%#&%%$&,#&61!""!3%"#432#ADK#'2!1(">#+$*#)3)$,&53%#
/238*.#!"#62!9(%#+-#*.(#&''$1$,&53%#34#3V(%6(2"#"(29!%/#1$'.#,3%/(2#
*.&%#*.(-#.&9(#.!"*32!'&,,-7#
L&)WPVG#O&10'=>&)#
Y""$1("#*.(#&%%$&,#)3)$,&53%#34#3V(%6(2"##
#!%'&2'(2&*(6#432#%3%NADK#3V(%"("#2(1&!%"#'3%"*&%*#&*#=<BB#,(9(,"7#
#
_.!"#!"#%3*#&#)23]('53%#34#*.(#%3%NADK#)3)$,&53%>#+$*#2&*.(2#&#"*&5'#
("51&*(7#_.!"#".&2(#34#*.(#)3)$,&53%#1&-#!%'2(&"(#32#6('2(&"(##
6()(%6!%/#3%#&%-#'.&%/(#!%#&61!""!3%"#32#,(%/*.#34#"*&-7#
Top Nonviolent Prison Admissions
(Cumulative FY05-FY10)
Council of State Governments Justice Center | 15 DOC Admissions, FY05-FY10.
Most People Admitted to Prison in 2010 Had Many Prior
Arrests, But Some Had Relatively Few
Council of State Governments Justice Center | 16 OSBI Arrest Data and Oklahoma Department of Corrections 2010 Reception Data
G\,&.31&#M*&*$*(#S(`%(6#a!3,(%*#
P2!1("# VQS# !@!V!# SQ#
O23)(2*-#&%6#G*.(2#O$+,!'#G26(2#
P2!1("# :ST# :@!RT# ::V#
S2$/#P2!1("# R.:# .@FFT# :QS#
BNC# ?NB@# BE##
32#132(#
b!4(51(#Y22("*#c9(%*"##
d!%',$6!%/#'$22(%*#&22("*e#
.Q!Q##
HI'=<&-=#XHJ#D7-%33%&)3#
Preliminary Analysis
Council of State Governments Justice Center | 17
!"#
$%&'()*#+,%-(##
!"#$%&''()*&+,-#.!/.0#
*.(#%$1+(2#34#)3,!'(#
)(2#'&)!*&#!%#*.2((#34#
*.(#,&2/("*#'!5("#.&"#
6(',!%(67#
#
."#
/01(,2%3%&)#4&,#
4('&)5#&6()7(,3#%3#
7(+'%)%)89#4(8(2#
)(3),(#&2(#+(!%/#
"$)(29!"(6#&:(2#
2(,(&"(#4231#)2!"3%7#
:"#
;<(#1,%3&)#
1&10'=>&)#%3#
8,&?%)8@#&%6#132(#
")(%6!%/#8!,,#+(#
2(;$!2(6#*3#!%'2(&"(#
'&)&'!*-#$%,(""#*.(#
)3)$,&53%#/238*.#!"#
1&%&/(67#
Council of State Governments Justice Center | 21
Thank You
John Estus
Press Secretary
Office of the Speaker
john.estus@okhouse.gov
www.jrioklahoma.com